The Chappelle list
Critics hated them. Audiences didn’t. The films with the biggest gaps between the critics’ and the audience’s Rotten Tomatoes scores.
- Citizen Vigilante (2026), directed by Uwe Boll · critics 14%, audiences 90%
- Stonewall (2015), directed by Roland Emmerich · critics 9%, audiences 84%
- Blacklight (2022), directed by Mark Williams · critics 11%, audiences 82%
- Life Itself (2018), directed by Dan Fogelman · critics 12%, audiences 83%
- Grandma's Boy (2006), directed by Nicholaus Goossen · critics 15%, audiences 85%
- Old Guy (2024), directed by Simon West · critics 26%, audiences 92%
- The Boondock Saints (1999), directed by Troy Duffy · critics 26%, audiences 91%
- The Tiger and the Snow (2005), directed by Roberto Benigni · critics 22%, audiences 84%
- The Life of David Gale (2003), directed by Alan Parker · critics 20%, audiences 81%
- Beyond Borders (2003), directed by Martin Campbell · critics 14%, audiences 72%
- Super Troopers (2001), directed by Jay Chandrasekhar · critics 33%, audiences 90%
- Hillbilly Elegy (2020), directed by Ron Howard · critics 24%, audiences 81%
- The War with Grandpa (2020), directed by Tim Hill · critics 29%, audiences 85%
- Angel Has Fallen (2019), directed by Ric Roman Waugh · critics 38%, audiences 93%
- Bad Boys II (2003), directed by Michael Bay · critics 23%, audiences 78%
- Practical Magic 2 (2026), directed by Susanne Bier · critics 36%, audiences 90%
- Half Baked (1998), directed by Tamra Davis · critics 27%, audiences 81%
- P.S. I Love You (2007), directed by Richard LaGravenese · critics 26%, audiences 80%
- John Q (2002), directed by Nick Cassavetes · critics 25%, audiences 78%
- The Phantom of the Opera (2004), directed by Joel Schumacher · critics 31%, audiences 84%
- Honey (2003), directed by Bille Woodruff · critics 18%, audiences 71%
- Death Wish (2018), directed by Eli Roth · critics 18%, audiences 70%
- Memory (2022), directed by Martin Campbell · critics 29%, audiences 80%
- Man on Fire (2004), directed by Tony Scott · critics 38%, audiences 89%
- Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls (1995), directed by Steve Oedekerk · critics 21%, audiences 72%
- Gone in 60 Seconds (2000), directed by Dominic Sena · critics 26%, audiences 77%
- Chaos Walking (2021), directed by Doug Liman · critics 21%, audiences 71%
- Midway (2019), directed by Roland Emmerich · critics 42%, audiences 92%
- I Am Sam (2001), directed by Jessie Nelson · critics 36%, audiences 86%
- Cirque du Soleil: Worlds Away (2012), directed by Andrew Adamson · critics 43%, audiences 93%
- Memoirs of a Geisha (2005), directed by Rob Marshall · critics 34%, audiences 83%
- Jurassic World Dominion (2022), directed by Colin Trevorrow · critics 28%, audiences 77%
- Patch Adams (1998), directed by Tom Shadyac · critics 24%, audiences 73%
- Law Abiding Citizen (2009), directed by F. Gary Gray · critics 26%, audiences 75%
- Empire Records (1995), directed by Allan Moyle · critics 35%, audiences 83%
- Anna (2019), directed by Luc Besson · critics 33%, audiences 81%
- The Goldfinch (2019), directed by John Crowley · critics 24%, audiences 72%
- The Comeback Trail (2020), directed by George Gallo · critics 31%, audiences 79%
- Coyote Ugly (2000), directed by David McNally · critics 23%, audiences 71%
- Please Don't Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain (2023), directed by Paul Briganti · critics 42%, audiences 89%
- Warcraft (2016), directed by Duncan Jones · critics 29%, audiences 76%
- Tommy Boy (1995), directed by Peter Segal · critics 43%, audiences 90%
- Radio (2003), directed by Michael Tollin · critics 32%, audiences 79%
- The Butterfly Effect (2004), directed by Eric Bress and J. Mackye Gruber · critics 35%, audiences 81%
- Honest Thief (2020), directed by Mark Williams · critics 41%, audiences 87%
- Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom (2023), directed by James Wan · critics 33%, audiences 79%
- The Marksman (2021), directed by Robert Lorenz · critics 38%, audiences 83%
- About My Father (2023), directed by Laura Terruso · critics 36%, audiences 81%
- Don't Be a Menace to South Central While Drinking Your Juice in the Hood (1996), directed by Paris Barclay · critics 35%, audiences 80%
- Between Worlds (2018), directed by Maria Pulera · critics 33%, audiences 78%
- The Baxter (2005), directed by Michael Showalter · critics 31%, audiences 75%
- Two Can Play That Game (2001), directed by Mark Brown · critics 39%, audiences 83%
- Kingdom Come (2001), directed by Doug McHenry · critics 28%, audiences 72%
- The Guardian (2006), directed by Andrew Davis · critics 37%, audiences 80%
- Practical Magic (1998), directed by Griffin Dunne · critics 31%, audiences 73%
- Where the Heart Is (2000), directed by Matt Williams · critics 34%, audiences 76%
- Life as a House (2001), directed by Irwin Winkler · critics 46%, audiences 88%
- Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019), directed by Michael Dougherty · critics 42%, audiences 83%
- Equilibrium (2002), directed by Kurt Wimmer · critics 40%, audiences 81%
- Imagine Me & You (2005), directed by Ol Parker · critics 33%, audiences 74%
- Ladder 49 (2004), directed by Jay Russell · critics 41%, audiences 81%
- Trade (2007), directed by Marco Kreuzpaintner · critics 34%, audiences 74%
- The Boys in the Boat (2023), directed by George Clooney · critics 57%, audiences 96%
- Robin Hood: Men in Tights (1993), directed by Mel Brooks · critics 42%, audiences 81%
- Center Stage (2000), directed by Nicholas Hytner · critics 43%, audiences 82%
- The Champ (1979), directed by Franco Zeffirelli · critics 42%, audiences 81%
- Tristan & Isolde (2006), directed by Kevin Reynolds · critics 32%, audiences 71%
- Billy Madison (1995), directed by Tamra Davis · critics 40%, audiences 79%
- Legend (1985), directed by Ridley Scott · critics 34%, audiences 73%
- Hook (1991), directed by Steven Spielberg · critics 37%, audiences 76%
- Sweet Home Alabama (2002), directed by Andy Tennant · critics 39%, audiences 78%
- Book Club: The Next Chapter (2023), directed by Bill Holderman · critics 46%, audiences 84%
- Inside I'm Dancing (2004), directed by Damien O'Donnell · critics 50%, audiences 88%
- Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998), directed by Terry Gilliam · critics 51%, audiences 89%
- The Upside (2017), directed by Neil Burger · critics 43%, audiences 81%
- Pay It Forward (2000), directed by Mimi Leder · critics 39%, audiences 77%
- Big Daddy (1999), directed by Dennis Dugan · critics 36%, audiences 74%
- Men of Honor (2000), directed by George Tillman, Jr. · critics 43%, audiences 81%
- Rent (2005), directed by Chris Columbus · critics 46%, audiences 83%
- The Chumscrubber (2005), directed by Arie Posin · critics 38%, audiences 75%
- Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore (2022), directed by David Yates · critics 46%, audiences 83%
- Aladdin (2019), directed by Guy Ritchie · critics 57%, audiences 94%
- The House of the Spirits (1993), directed by Bille August · critics 34%, audiences 71%
- The Bucket List (2007), directed by Rob Reiner · critics 40%, audiences 77%
- Chasing Mavericks (2012), directed by Curtis Hanson and Michael Apted · critics 33%, audiences 70%
- Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990), directed by Steve Barron · critics 44%, audiences 81%
- Martian Child (2007), directed by Menno Meyjes · critics 35%, audiences 72%
- Don't Worry Darling (2022), directed by Olivia Wilde · critics 38%, audiences 74%
- Kandahar (2023), directed by Ric Roman Waugh · critics 46%, audiences 82%
- The Legend of Billie Jean (1985), directed by Matthew Robbins · critics 39%, audiences 75%
- The Lion King (2019), directed by Jon Favreau · critics 52%, audiences 88%
- Ocean's 11 (1960), directed by Lewis Milestone · critics 45%, audiences 81%
- Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania (2023), directed by Peyton Reed · critics 46%, audiences 81%
- Radio Flyer (1992), directed by David M. Evans and Richard Donner · critics 37%, audiences 72%
- The Sheltering Sky (1990), directed by Bernardo Bertolucci · critics 44%, audiences 79%
- Beyond Rangoon (1995), directed by John Boorman · critics 36%, audiences 71%
- Champs (2014), directed by Bert Marcus · critics 57%, audiences 92%
- Star Wars: Episode IX – The Rise of Skywalker (2019), directed by J. J. Abrams · critics 51%, audiences 86%
- Wet Hot American Summer (2001), directed by David Wain · critics 40%, audiences 75%
- Lucky Number Slevin (2006), directed by Paul McGuigan · critics 52%, audiences 87%