Auteur

The Chappelle list

Critics hated them. Audiences didn’t. The films with the biggest gaps between the critics’ and the audience’s Rotten Tomatoes scores.

  1. Citizen Vigilante (2026), directed by Uwe Boll · critics 14%, audiences 90%
  2. Stonewall (2015), directed by Roland Emmerich · critics 9%, audiences 84%
  3. Blacklight (2022), directed by Mark Williams · critics 11%, audiences 82%
  4. Life Itself (2018), directed by Dan Fogelman · critics 12%, audiences 83%
  5. Grandma's Boy (2006), directed by Nicholaus Goossen · critics 15%, audiences 85%
  6. Old Guy (2024), directed by Simon West · critics 26%, audiences 92%
  7. The Boondock Saints (1999), directed by Troy Duffy · critics 26%, audiences 91%
  8. The Tiger and the Snow (2005), directed by Roberto Benigni · critics 22%, audiences 84%
  9. The Life of David Gale (2003), directed by Alan Parker · critics 20%, audiences 81%
  10. Beyond Borders (2003), directed by Martin Campbell · critics 14%, audiences 72%
  11. Super Troopers (2001), directed by Jay Chandrasekhar · critics 33%, audiences 90%
  12. Hillbilly Elegy (2020), directed by Ron Howard · critics 24%, audiences 81%
  13. The War with Grandpa (2020), directed by Tim Hill · critics 29%, audiences 85%
  14. Angel Has Fallen (2019), directed by Ric Roman Waugh · critics 38%, audiences 93%
  15. Bad Boys II (2003), directed by Michael Bay · critics 23%, audiences 78%
  16. Practical Magic 2 (2026), directed by Susanne Bier · critics 36%, audiences 90%
  17. Half Baked (1998), directed by Tamra Davis · critics 27%, audiences 81%
  18. P.S. I Love You (2007), directed by Richard LaGravenese · critics 26%, audiences 80%
  19. John Q (2002), directed by Nick Cassavetes · critics 25%, audiences 78%
  20. The Phantom of the Opera (2004), directed by Joel Schumacher · critics 31%, audiences 84%
  21. Honey (2003), directed by Bille Woodruff · critics 18%, audiences 71%
  22. Death Wish (2018), directed by Eli Roth · critics 18%, audiences 70%
  23. Memory (2022), directed by Martin Campbell · critics 29%, audiences 80%
  24. Man on Fire (2004), directed by Tony Scott · critics 38%, audiences 89%
  25. Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls (1995), directed by Steve Oedekerk · critics 21%, audiences 72%
  26. Gone in 60 Seconds (2000), directed by Dominic Sena · critics 26%, audiences 77%
  27. Chaos Walking (2021), directed by Doug Liman · critics 21%, audiences 71%
  28. Midway (2019), directed by Roland Emmerich · critics 42%, audiences 92%
  29. I Am Sam (2001), directed by Jessie Nelson · critics 36%, audiences 86%
  30. Cirque du Soleil: Worlds Away (2012), directed by Andrew Adamson · critics 43%, audiences 93%
  31. Memoirs of a Geisha (2005), directed by Rob Marshall · critics 34%, audiences 83%
  32. Jurassic World Dominion (2022), directed by Colin Trevorrow · critics 28%, audiences 77%
  33. Patch Adams (1998), directed by Tom Shadyac · critics 24%, audiences 73%
  34. Law Abiding Citizen (2009), directed by F. Gary Gray · critics 26%, audiences 75%
  35. Empire Records (1995), directed by Allan Moyle · critics 35%, audiences 83%
  36. Anna (2019), directed by Luc Besson · critics 33%, audiences 81%
  37. The Goldfinch (2019), directed by John Crowley · critics 24%, audiences 72%
  38. The Comeback Trail (2020), directed by George Gallo · critics 31%, audiences 79%
  39. Coyote Ugly (2000), directed by David McNally · critics 23%, audiences 71%
  40. Please Don't Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain (2023), directed by Paul Briganti · critics 42%, audiences 89%
  41. Warcraft (2016), directed by Duncan Jones · critics 29%, audiences 76%
  42. Tommy Boy (1995), directed by Peter Segal · critics 43%, audiences 90%
  43. Radio (2003), directed by Michael Tollin · critics 32%, audiences 79%
  44. The Butterfly Effect (2004), directed by Eric Bress and J. Mackye Gruber · critics 35%, audiences 81%
  45. Honest Thief (2020), directed by Mark Williams · critics 41%, audiences 87%
  46. Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom (2023), directed by James Wan · critics 33%, audiences 79%
  47. The Marksman (2021), directed by Robert Lorenz · critics 38%, audiences 83%
  48. About My Father (2023), directed by Laura Terruso · critics 36%, audiences 81%
  49. Don't Be a Menace to South Central While Drinking Your Juice in the Hood (1996), directed by Paris Barclay · critics 35%, audiences 80%
  50. Between Worlds (2018), directed by Maria Pulera · critics 33%, audiences 78%
  51. The Baxter (2005), directed by Michael Showalter · critics 31%, audiences 75%
  52. Two Can Play That Game (2001), directed by Mark Brown · critics 39%, audiences 83%
  53. Kingdom Come (2001), directed by Doug McHenry · critics 28%, audiences 72%
  54. The Guardian (2006), directed by Andrew Davis · critics 37%, audiences 80%
  55. Practical Magic (1998), directed by Griffin Dunne · critics 31%, audiences 73%
  56. Where the Heart Is (2000), directed by Matt Williams · critics 34%, audiences 76%
  57. Life as a House (2001), directed by Irwin Winkler · critics 46%, audiences 88%
  58. Godzilla: King of the Monsters (2019), directed by Michael Dougherty · critics 42%, audiences 83%
  59. Equilibrium (2002), directed by Kurt Wimmer · critics 40%, audiences 81%
  60. Imagine Me & You (2005), directed by Ol Parker · critics 33%, audiences 74%
  61. Ladder 49 (2004), directed by Jay Russell · critics 41%, audiences 81%
  62. Trade (2007), directed by Marco Kreuzpaintner · critics 34%, audiences 74%
  63. The Boys in the Boat (2023), directed by George Clooney · critics 57%, audiences 96%
  64. Robin Hood: Men in Tights (1993), directed by Mel Brooks · critics 42%, audiences 81%
  65. Center Stage (2000), directed by Nicholas Hytner · critics 43%, audiences 82%
  66. The Champ (1979), directed by Franco Zeffirelli · critics 42%, audiences 81%
  67. Tristan & Isolde (2006), directed by Kevin Reynolds · critics 32%, audiences 71%
  68. Billy Madison (1995), directed by Tamra Davis · critics 40%, audiences 79%
  69. Legend (1985), directed by Ridley Scott · critics 34%, audiences 73%
  70. Hook (1991), directed by Steven Spielberg · critics 37%, audiences 76%
  71. Sweet Home Alabama (2002), directed by Andy Tennant · critics 39%, audiences 78%
  72. Book Club: The Next Chapter (2023), directed by Bill Holderman · critics 46%, audiences 84%
  73. Inside I'm Dancing (2004), directed by Damien O'Donnell · critics 50%, audiences 88%
  74. Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas (1998), directed by Terry Gilliam · critics 51%, audiences 89%
  75. The Upside (2017), directed by Neil Burger · critics 43%, audiences 81%
  76. Pay It Forward (2000), directed by Mimi Leder · critics 39%, audiences 77%
  77. Big Daddy (1999), directed by Dennis Dugan · critics 36%, audiences 74%
  78. Men of Honor (2000), directed by George Tillman, Jr. · critics 43%, audiences 81%
  79. Rent (2005), directed by Chris Columbus · critics 46%, audiences 83%
  80. The Chumscrubber (2005), directed by Arie Posin · critics 38%, audiences 75%
  81. Fantastic Beasts: The Secrets of Dumbledore (2022), directed by David Yates · critics 46%, audiences 83%
  82. Aladdin (2019), directed by Guy Ritchie · critics 57%, audiences 94%
  83. The House of the Spirits (1993), directed by Bille August · critics 34%, audiences 71%
  84. The Bucket List (2007), directed by Rob Reiner · critics 40%, audiences 77%
  85. Chasing Mavericks (2012), directed by Curtis Hanson and Michael Apted · critics 33%, audiences 70%
  86. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (1990), directed by Steve Barron · critics 44%, audiences 81%
  87. Martian Child (2007), directed by Menno Meyjes · critics 35%, audiences 72%
  88. Don't Worry Darling (2022), directed by Olivia Wilde · critics 38%, audiences 74%
  89. Kandahar (2023), directed by Ric Roman Waugh · critics 46%, audiences 82%
  90. The Legend of Billie Jean (1985), directed by Matthew Robbins · critics 39%, audiences 75%
  91. The Lion King (2019), directed by Jon Favreau · critics 52%, audiences 88%
  92. Ocean's 11 (1960), directed by Lewis Milestone · critics 45%, audiences 81%
  93. Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania (2023), directed by Peyton Reed · critics 46%, audiences 81%
  94. Radio Flyer (1992), directed by David M. Evans and Richard Donner · critics 37%, audiences 72%
  95. The Sheltering Sky (1990), directed by Bernardo Bertolucci · critics 44%, audiences 79%
  96. Beyond Rangoon (1995), directed by John Boorman · critics 36%, audiences 71%
  97. Champs (2014), directed by Bert Marcus · critics 57%, audiences 92%
  98. Star Wars: Episode IX – The Rise of Skywalker (2019), directed by J. J. Abrams · critics 51%, audiences 86%
  99. Wet Hot American Summer (2001), directed by David Wain · critics 40%, audiences 75%
  100. Lucky Number Slevin (2006), directed by Paul McGuigan · critics 52%, audiences 87%