Love it or hate it
The films that split their audience, from Trakt members’ 1-to-10 votes. Which side are you on?
- Fred: The Movie (2010), directed by Brian Robbins and Clay Weiner · critics 0%, audiences 42%
- Fred 2: Night of the Living Fred (2011), directed by John Fortenberry
- Citizen Vigilante (2026), directed by Uwe Boll · critics 14%, audiences 90%
- After We Collided (2020), directed by Roger Kumble · critics 13%, audiences 93%
- Spice World (1997), directed by Bob Spiers · critics 35%, audiences 45%
- The Forbidden Room (2015), directed by Guy Maddin · critics 96%, audiences 51%
- The Birth of a Nation (1915), directed by D. W. Griffith · critics 90%, audiences 40%
- Emilia Pérez (2024), directed by Jacques Audiard · critics 70%, audiences 73%
- After (2019), directed by Jenny Gage · critics 18%, audiences 64%
- Smosh: The Movie (2015), directed by Alex Winter
- Fifty Shades Freed (2018), directed by James Foley · critics 11%, audiences 38%
- Crossroads (2002), directed by Tamra Davis · critics 15%, audiences 40%
- Fifty Shades of Grey (2015), directed by Sam Taylor-Johnson · critics 25%, audiences 41%
- Snow White (2025), directed by Marc Webb · critics 39%, audiences 69%
- Not Another Church Movie (2024), directed by Johnny Mack · critics 13%, audiences 21%
- Bucky Larson: Born to Be a Star (2011), directed by Tom Brady · critics 3%, audiences 26%
- Happily N'Ever After 2: Snow White—Another Bite @ the Apple (2009), directed by Boyd Kirkland and Steven E. Gordon
- Postal (2007), directed by Uwe Boll · critics 9%, audiences 36%
- The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1 (2011), directed by Bill Condon · critics 25%, audiences 60%
- The Stupids (1996), directed by John Landis · critics 20%, audiences 38%
- The Cat in the Hat (2003), directed by Bo Welch · critics 11%, audiences 59%
- Jack and Jill (2011), directed by Dennis Dugan · critics 3%, audiences 36%
- Nina (2016), directed by Cynthia Mort · critics 2%, audiences 25%
- Twilight (2008), directed by Catherine Hardwicke · critics 48%, audiences 72%
- Hell Ride (2008), directed by Larry Bishop · critics 10%, audiences 31%
- The Twilight Saga: New Moon (2009), directed by Chris Weitz · critics 28%, audiences 61%
- The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 2 (2012), directed by Bill Condon · critics 49%, audiences 70%
- Sharknado 2: The Second One (2014), directed by Anthony C. Ferrante · critics 61%, audiences 35%
- Dead Man Running (2009), directed by Alex De Rakoff · critics 14%, audiences 52%
- The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010), directed by David Slade · critics 46%, audiences 60%
- Left Behind (2014), directed by Vic Armstrong · critics 0%, audiences 21%
- Curious George 2: Follow That Monkey! (2010), directed by Norton Virgien
- Ukraine on Fire (2016), directed by Igor Lopatonok
- Bingo (1991), directed by Matthew Robbins
- I Dreamed of Africa (2000), directed by Hugh Hudson · critics 10%, audiences 56%
- Pawn Shop Chronicles (2013), directed by Wayne Kramer
- Double Take (2001), directed by George Gallo · critics 13%, audiences 50%
- An American Carol (2008), directed by David Zucker · critics 13%, audiences 48%
- What? (1972), directed by Roman Polanski · critics 17%, audiences 47%
- Marmaduke (2010), directed by Tom Dey · critics 9%, audiences 42%
- Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World (2023), directed by Radu Jude · critics 95%, audiences 69%
- Sunset (1988), directed by Blake Edwards · critics 21%, audiences 29%
- Breakfast of Champions (1999), directed by Alan Rudolph · critics 27%, audiences 32%
- Pinocchio (2002), directed by Roberto Benigni · critics 0%, audiences 34%
- Juwanna Mann (2002), directed by Jesse Vaughan · critics 9%, audiences 40%
- A Dirty Shame (2004), directed by John Waters · critics 55%, audiences 51%
- Who's That Girl (1987), directed by James Foley · critics 30%, audiences 48%
- Santa Baby (2006), directed by Ron Underwood
- Scary Movie 5 (2013), directed by Malcolm D. Lee · critics 4%, audiences 38%
- Artemis Fowl (2020), directed by Kenneth Branagh · critics 8%, audiences 19%
- Bring It On: Worldwide #Cheersmack (2017), directed by Robert Adetuyi
- Burning Palms (2010), directed by Christopher Landon · critics 38%, audiences 35%
- The Prom (2020), directed by Ryan Murphy · critics 54%, audiences 61%
- Casino Royale (1967), directed by John Huston and Joseph McGrath · critics 28%, audiences 33%
- Between Worlds (2018), directed by Maria Pulera · critics 33%, audiences 78%
- Strange Wilderness (2008), directed by Fred Wolf · critics 2%, audiences 35%
- Santa Baby 2 (2009), directed by Ron Underwood
- Cannonball Run II (1984), directed by Hal Needham · critics 13%, audiences 45%
- Katy Perry: Part of Me (2012), directed by Dan Cutforth and Jane Lipsitz · critics 76%, audiences 72%
- Curse of the Pink Panther (1983), directed by Blake Edwards · critics 29%, audiences 22%
- Aquarium of the Dead (2021), directed by Glenn Miller
- Superhero Movie (2008), directed by Craig Mazin · critics 17%, audiences 33%
- Hercules in New York (1970), directed by Arthur Allan Seidelman · critics 14%, audiences 27%
- Endless Love (1981), directed by Franco Zeffirelli · critics 29%, audiences 50%
- In the Name of the King 2: Two Worlds (2011), directed by Uwe Boll
- Mercenaries (2014), directed by Christopher Ray
- Haven (2004), directed by Frank E. Flowers · critics 15%, audiences 59%
- Zandalee (1991), directed by Sam Pillsbury
- The Virginity Hit (2010), directed by Huck Botko · critics 26%, audiences 31%
- Superstar (1999), directed by Bruce McCulloch · critics 34%, audiences 59%
- The Lost Chapter: Yuki's Revenge (2025), directed by Quentin Tarantino
- She Hate Me (2004), directed by Spike Lee · critics 18%, audiences 59%
- Seed (2007), directed by Uwe Boll
- Saint John of Las Vegas (2009), directed by Hue Rhodes · critics 22%, audiences 27%
- Taxi (2004), directed by Tim Story · critics 9%, audiences 43%
- Queen of the Desert (2015), directed by Werner Herzog · critics 17%, audiences 37%
- Trail of the Pink Panther (1982), directed by Blake Edwards · critics 23%, audiences 32%
- Thunderbirds (2004), directed by Jonathan Frakes · critics 19%, audiences 37%
- Pound of Flesh (2015), directed by Ernie Barbarash · critics 15%, audiences 22%
- Blueberry (2004), directed by Jan Kounen · critics 25%, audiences 49%
- Stonewall (2015), directed by Roland Emmerich · critics 9%, audiences 84%
- The Wilde Wedding (2017), directed by Damian Harris · critics 21%, audiences 20%
- Ass Backwards (2013), directed by Chris Nelson · critics 29%, audiences 18%
- Jaws: The Revenge (1987), directed by Joseph Sargent · critics 2%, audiences 15%
- Cheaper by the Dozen (2022), directed by Gail Lerner · critics 36%, audiences 33%
- The Collective (2023), directed by Tom DeNucci
- Tiptoes (2003), directed by Matthew Bright · critics 29%, audiences 24%
- Showgirls (1995), directed by Paul Verhoeven · critics 24%, audiences 38%
- Jaws 3-D (1983), directed by Joe Alves · critics 10%, audiences 17%
- The Star Wars Holiday Special (1978), directed by David Acomba and Steve Binder · critics 25%, audiences 24%
- Holiday in Handcuffs (2007), directed by Ron Underwood
- The Runner (2015), directed by Austin Stark · critics 24%, audiences 22%
- Every Thing Will Be Fine (2015), directed by Wim Wenders · critics 28%, audiences 24%
- Kickin' It Old Skool (2007), directed by Harvey Glazer · critics 2%, audiences 42%
- Suddenly (2013), directed by Uwe Boll
- Howard the Duck (1986), directed by Willard Huyck · critics 14%, audiences 38%
- Bride Hard (2025), directed by Simon West · critics 14%, audiences 58%
- Spanish Movie (2009), directed by Javier Ruiz Caldera
- The Benefactor (2015), directed by Andrew Renzi · critics 26%, audiences 24%
- More American Graffiti (1979), directed by Bill L. Norton · critics 27%, audiences 33%